The selection of the selling agent is usually decided upon from an interview and/or a sales proposal process. Whether it's an interview or a sales proposal that you are using to determine your agent, neither actually shows the agent in action. Agents are fully rehearsed with scripts and dialogues to ensure a slick presentation when they are being interviewed by sellers.
Given you are employing an agent to market, sell and negotiate the sale of your home, it is worth seeing them in action. To gain a true perspective of the agents you are considering, mystery shop them as a buyer. When you mystery shop the agent, ask a few probing questions.
You will quickly gain an insight into whether you want that agent representing you. Questions such as 'why hasn't the property sold yet?' or 'do you have sales evidence to justify the price guide?' can garner surprising answers. Every agent will find it easy to hold the line with a new listing that has a lot of interest in it.
However, you will get a better perspective of the agent's ability if you mystery shop them on one of their failed auctions or struggling campaigns. Look for clues as to whether the agent is protecting their client's interests or breaching confidence. The best agents are the best at protecting their clients, even when the campaign is not going to script.
A dangerous agent for the seller is one that becomes desperate when the campaign does not go as expected. All agents look good when there are 3 buyers trying to buy 1 house. How does that same agent look when the property has failed at auction, the advertising money has been spent (wasted) and the crowds have stopped turning up to the open inspection?
What you want to see when you mystery shop an agent
Available and follow up - In order to mystery shop an agent, you first want one that is available. Does the agent respond to messages? It is a phenomenon in real estate that the stronger the market, the worse the service buyers receive from agents. Essentially, in a boom, service to buyers goes down as agents' advertising for buyers goes up!
Does the agent follow up and follow through? If you asked for information, did they get it to you? Were you followed up after the inspection for feedback and a second inspection? Were you informed of similar properties being listed the week after you inspected? Is a senior or listing agent handling your enquiry or was it the office junior that started in real estate last week? Once you mystery shop an agent, what happens from that point can offer all of the information you need to make a listing decision.
Enthusiasm - Was the agent enthusiastic about the property and you as a buyer?
Knowledge - The best agents have thorough knowledge of the property and the local area. If there is a question the agent cannot answer on the spot, the agent chases the answer and responds. Assertiveness - Look for agents that are pleasant but assertive. When you ask probing questions to test the agents, they confidently and assertively protect their clients.
A pleasant pleaser won't help you when the negotiating gets down to the pointy end of proceedings.
What you don't want to see when you mystery shop an agent
Personal details disclosed - If you walk into an inspection and leave feeling as though you know the owners life story, because the agent divulged all, that's not a good thing. It is a terrible betrayal actually. When you are mystery shopping agents, ask probing questions of the agent to see how they handle them.
If you find out that the owners are selling because 'the job loss caused financial difficulties that led to stress in the marriage, that saw one of the owners begin an affair which was the cause of the divorce' then don't hire the agent.
Short, rude or unavailable - The best sales - people know that the next enquiry could be the best buyer. Conversely, if the agent is abrasive and pre-judges buyers, they are likely to turn buyers off the home.
What other buyers have offered - Some agents will freely disclose the offers that have been made by other buyers.This breeds instant mistrust in buyers. If offers are disclosed to you, expect yours to be disclosed to others.
An agent that freely discloses offers during the campaign is effectively running a ‘Dutch auction’.The property will be ‘sold to the buyer that offers the best price’ is a simple and assertive response that negates a messy Dutch auction.
There are many elements to selecting the right agent. The most dangerous (and lazy) selection method is to request 3 agents to inspect your home and send a written sales proposal through. Given $50,000 or $100,000 can be easily made, won or lost by the agent during the campaign, it is worth finding the right agent.